Nov 21: Patients in hospitals and doctors’ offices are routinely asked to rate their pain on a scale from zero to 10. But what does that number actually communicate? Does a seven mean the same thing to every patient—and does it mean the same thing to the physician treating them?
These are among the questions driving the research of Tannistha Sarkar, a PhD candidate in sociology at the UC San Diego School of Social Sciences. Sarkar studies how patients experience, interpret and communicate pain, as well as how doctors make sense of those accounts in clinical settings.
Her work explores questions that extend well beyond the numerical scale: How does an injury disrupt a person’s identity and everyday life? Why do some people become more cautious after an injury, while others focus on returning to the activity that caused it? And how do risk, uncertainty and hope influence the stories patients tell about their pain?
Sarkar sat down with University Communications to discuss what she has learned so far and why understanding pain requires looking at the relationship between medicine and society.
What does a pain score mean to patients and doctors?
Unlike blood pressure or body temperature, pain cannot be measured directly. A pain score is an attempt to translate a deeply personal experience into a number that a health care provider can understand. I see it as a first bridge between a patient and a provider, but it cannot communicate the full experience. One number can hide an enormous amount of information about what a person is feeling, what happened to them and how that injury is affecting their life.
In my initial fieldwork, I found that patients generally understood the purpose of the scale, but they did not necessarily think of their pain as one fixed number. They often gave different scores for different moments in their pain recovery process—immediately after the injury, after surgery or later in recovery. They also understood that their 10 might be someone else’s 7 or 8.
Recent work has shown that doctors and nurses have become suspicious of the pain scale. I also encountered some of this suspicion amongst the healthcare workers that I interacted with as part of this project. I am looking into understanding the specific role of the pain scale within the clinic.
Why might two patients with similar injuries report very different levels of pain?
Pain is subjective, but that does not mean it is arbitrary. People interpret a new injury by comparing it with the experiences they have already had.
The pain score may look like a simple number, but behind that number is a person’s medical history, social background, cultural understanding and previous experience with pain.
How do injuries affect how a patient see themselves?
In medical sociology, we look at how an illness can interrupt a person’s daily routines, plans and sense of who they are. Much of that research has focused on chronic illness and chronic pain. I want to know whether acute pain can produce a similar rupture.
An acute injury may suddenly prevent someone from working, caring for family members or participating in an activity that is central to their identity. A cyclist may not speak primarily about pain because the more urgent question is, “When can I cycle again?” Someone who works with their hands may wonder whether they will still be able to do their job.
The injury affects the body, but the disruption extends into the person’s identity and imagined future. That is what makes acute pain sociologically interesting. I am looking at how people begin to orient themselves to a changed body and to a life that, at least temporarily, may not work the way it did before.
Does experiencing acute pain after an injury make people more cautious about taking risks?
We might assume that a serious injury would make someone avoid the activity that caused it. Research on older adults who are injured in falls, for example, has shown that some become very cautious afterward or stop doing certain activities because they fear falling again.
But that does not always appear to be the case. Athletes, dancers and people who enjoy adventurous activities may experience repeated injuries and still return to what they love. The activity may be so important to their identity that the injury becomes something to recover from rather than a reason to stop.
What sense and meaning do people make of their injury and subsequent recovery process?
The injuries experienced by the patients are imbued with meaning that take different forms based on whether they get injured playing sports, or injured randomly either at work or from a fall. I find there is hope for patients whether they get injured playing sports or injured randomly either at work or from a fall, but it may take different forms. For someone injured while cycling, hope might be attached to a concrete goal: recovering in time for the next competition. For someone hurt unexpectedly at work, hope may first require making sense of why the injury occurred and whether ordinary life will feel safe again.
Why is pain a subject for sociology?
People often think of acute pain as purely physical and therefore something only medicine can explain. But pain also has emotional, cognitive, social and cultural dimensions. How people understand pain, how comfortable they feel expressing it and whether their account is believed can all be shaped by their social world.
Sociologists also look closely at what happens during the medical encounter. Patients have much more to say about their experiences than can fit into a brief appointment. In my research, I distinguish between a short-form pain narrative—the focused account a patient gives a doctor—and the long-form narrative that emerges during an extended interview. Comparing the two helps me see what patients emphasize, what they leave out and why.
Medical sociology can help make those often-invisible forces visible. In that sense, I am a bridge between patients and doctors. I listen to how patients describe their experiences, observe how those accounts are interpreted in medical settings and try to understand what may be getting lost between the two.
